PETITION TO ESTABLISH 'SANTA RITA HILLS' AVA
Drafted by Wesley D. Hagen, Vineyard Manager, Clos Pepe Vineyards
Voice: (805) 735-2196 Fax: (805) 736-5907
Petition:
This document constitutes a petition from viticulturists and vintners working in the Santa
Rita subarea of Santa Barbara County, California. Under the direction of Richard
Sanford (Sanford Winery), Bryan Babcock (Babcock Vineyards and Winery), and
Wesley D. Hagen (Clos Pepe Vineyards), this petition proposes to establish a new
American Viticultural Area (AVA) located within the Western Santa Ynez Valley,
California to be known as 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA.
Currently more than fifteen vineyards exist within the proposed 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA
boundary, with more than five hundred acres planted to varietal winegrapes.
Bonded wineries that currently source or vinify grapes from the proposed AVA
boundary include: Au Bon Climat/Qupe/Hartley-Ostini/Cold Heaven Winery, Babcock
Winery, Foxen Winery, Gainey Winery, Longoria-Rideau Winery, Morovino Winery,
Ojai Vineyards, Fess Parker Winery, Presidio Winery, Rusack Winery, Sanford
Winery, Santa Barbara Winery, Sunstone Winery, and Whitcraft Winery.
Wholesalers/negotiants that vinify grapes from this region include:
Brewer-Clifton, and Fiddlehead Cellars.
This cool-climate winegrape growing region is being developed at a rapid pace, and the planted
acreage is expected to double within the next five to ten years.

Evidence That the Name of the Proposed Area is Locally or Nationally Known:
It is clear that the Santa Rita Hills, a range of rolling mountains between Buellton and
Lompoc, California are central to the geography of the proposed AVA. Enclosed
Spanish Land Grant maps, USGS Quadrangle maps, and Santa Ynez River Water
Conservation District maps show that the designation of 'Santa Rita' and 'Santa
Rita Hills' are both recognized as political, geographical, and historical
appellations. (See Exhibit One and Exhibit Three) Exhibit One shows specific
boundaries of Land Grants and actual copies of the U.S. Patent Book on which
they were inscribed. Exhibit One also shows locations of vineyards and wineries
that existed in the Santa Rita Hills area previous to the year 1900. Exhibit
Three shows U.S. Geological Survey maps that distinguish the 'Santa Rita
Syncline', the 'Santa Rita Upland', the 'Santa Rita Subarea' and the 'Santa Rita
Valley'. Exhibit Seven includes 7.5 minute series U.S.G.S. maps clearly
demarcating the 'Santa Rita Hills' as a dominant, central geological and
geographical feature of the proposed AVA boundary.

Historical or Current Evidence that the Boundaries
of the Proposed Viticultural Area Are as Specified in the Petition:
The proposed boundaries of the 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA have been carefully researched and
selected by a committee of viticulturists, consultants and vintners with formal
geological, geographic and agricultural education. Included on this committee
were: Robert Atkin (Sanford and Benedict Vineyard), Bryan Babcock (Babcock
Vineyards and Winery), Greg Brewer (Brewer-Clifton and Santa Barbara Winery)
Peter Cargasacchi (Cargasacchi Vineyards), Dan Gainey (Gainey Vineyards and
Winery), Wesley Hagen (Clos Pepe Vineyards), Rick Longoria (Longoria Wines),
Craig Macmillan (Macmillan Wine Company), Bruce McGuire (Santa Barbara Winery),
Jeff Newton (Coastal Vineyard Care) and Eli Parker (Fess Parker Vineyards and
Winery). The proposed boundaries have been surveyed site by site, hilltop to
hilltop, both on maps and in the field, to ensure that every square foot of the
proposed AVA represents those localities well-suited for cool-climate (Region
One) varietal winegrape production.
As evidenced by the USGS Quadrangle Maps (Exhibit Seven) submitted for approval, the Santa Rita
Hills are the dominant, central feature of the proposed AVA: a transverse
(east/west) maritime throat stretching from Lompoc to a few miles west of the
Buellton Flats. The area demarcated on the map is isolated geographically and
climatically by the Santa Rosa Hills to the south and the Purisima Hills to the
north. Maps contained in Exhibit One clearly illustrate how the proposed 'Santa
Rita Hills AVA' boundary shares land with the 'Santa Rita Syncline', the 'Santa
Rita Subarea', the 'Santa Rita Valley', and the 'Santa Rita Land Grant'of April
12, 1845.

History and Tradition:
Santa Rita was distinguished as a recognized political and geographical region on April 12,
1845 as land granted to Ramon Malo from Spanish Governor Pio Pico. The title was
confirmed to Jose Ramon Malo on June 25, 1875 by President Ulysses S. Grant as
confirmed in U.S. Patent Book 'A', page 277 (see Exhibit One, pages 1-4). The
patent issued included 13,316 acres within the boundary of the Santa Rita Land
Grant.
The text to follow comes from Owen O'Neill's History of Santa Barbara County, printed
by the Union Printing Company in 1939: "Following the secularization of the
Mission La Purisima, the rest of the valley was broken up into seven great
ranchos granted to private owners. They were the Santa Rosa, Santa Rita, Salsipuedes, La Purisima, Mission Vieja, Lompoc and a portion of the Jesus
Maria." (p.345, bold text added for emphasis)
Winegrapes have been grown in the Santa Rita area of Santa Barbara County since the nineteenth
century. Early growers and priestly vintners used the Mission grape to vinify
sacramental wines at Mission La Purisima near Lompoc. See Exhibit One, Page Five
for documentation of winemaking in this region before the year 1900. Even then,
the priests noticed that the Santa Rita Hills climate was too cool for the
Mission grape, and they found it was not ripening as well as some of the
plantings further inland. The maritime climate and sandy/alluvial soils have
provided Santa Rita farmers with excellent cultivation conditions for U.C. Davis
Region One crops for over a hundred years: flowers, peppers, beans, broccoli,
lettuce, and other cool-weather vegetables.
Contained within Exhibit Four are maps which show the location of vineyards established within
the proposed 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA and documentation proving the numerous and
distinct macro and mesoclimates present within the Santa Barbara area.
Discovering which geographical appellations are best suited to differing
varieties of winegrapes has been a long and fascinating part of Santa Barbara's
wine history -- and documents contained within Exhibit Four show how vintners have
focused on the Santa Rita Hills area as a premier area for growing Region One,
cool-climate winegrape varietals. Jeff Newton, who owns and operates Coastal
Vineyard Care, a consulting firm that manages ranches on both sides of the Santa
Ynez Valley, is quoted on page four of Exhibit Four as saying, "The best
Chardonnays and Pinots come from the cooler areas west of U.S. 101 closer to the
sea, and the best Sauvignon Blanc and reds like Cabernet from the warmer region
to the east. But no one knew this 20 years ago." It is evident now that more
information has been collected that these two areas of the Santa Ynez Valley
(east and west) are geographically, geologically, and viticulturally distinct.
On page five, Exhibit Four, a passage from Aged in Oak, a book describing the
history of Santa Barbara County's wine industry, makes the following assertion:
"If you divide the area along geographical lines, six possible itineraries
present themselves: 1. Buellton-Lompoc Loop... 2. Santa Ynez/Ballard... [etc.]"
(Aged in Oak, published by Santa Barbara
County Vintners' Association, 1998, researched by U.C. Santa Barbara Graduate
Program in Public Historical Studies. Chap. 3, page 6.) Other quotes in Exhibit
Four show the early plantings in this area -- the Sanford and Benedict Vineyard in
1971, the Lafond Vineyard in 1972, and the Babcock and Sweeney Canyon Vineyards
in 1980. Exhibit Four also illustrates how wines from this area met with swift
critical success from wine critics and collectors, and shows the focus on
Burgundian, cool-climate varietals such as Pinot Noir and
Chardonnay.
Within the last few decades, and the last five years specifically, this unique transverse range has
been recognized viticulturally and enologically for producing world-class,
cool-climate winegrape varietals such as Pinot Noir and Chardonnay.
Knowledgeable vintners continue to seek out the grapes grown in this area, and
the new plantings in this region are truly extensive. Wine and vineyard writers
have increasingly isolated this region as the premier Californian Central Coast
appellation for cool-climate varietal winegrapes. The following praise for the
region was penned by Hugh Johnson, the world renowned English wine writer, in
his World Atlas of Wine: Fourth Edition: "The true excitement of Santa
Ynez, though, lies westward towards Lompoc and the ocean, where the Sanford and
Benedict vineyard occupies a sheltered north-facing niche that perfectly suits
Pinot Noir and Chardonnay... In the right hands this is California's best Pinot
Noir so far." (Johnson, World Atlas of Wine, p.264) Such praise from one
of the world's greatest authorities on wine, distinguishing the Santa Rita Hills
area as producing California's 'best Pinot Noir', certainly supports
establishing this distinct region as its own American Viticultural Area.
Vintners working with Santa Rita Hills fruit do not wish to confuse wine consumers by using the
existing Santa Ynez Valley AVA on their (cool-climate) wine labels. The purpose
of the AVA system is to provide consumers with clear and accurate information
concerning climatic and geographical influences that produce wines of widely
disparate taste, varietal expression, and quality. The largest grape-growing
portion of the Santa Ynez AVA, east of Buellton and U.S Highway 101, is clearly
a Davis Region Two winegrape production locale, as opposed to the Davis Region
One classification of Santa Rita Hills, which lies west of Buellton, California.
Using the Santa Ynez Valley AVA designation for the cool-climate varietal wines
grown in the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA may lead to misinformed consumers and
mislabeled products -- exactly what the AVA system was designed to curtail.
Exhibit Six, letters of support, shows clearly that vintners vinifying fruit grown in the
proposed 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA feel the grapes to be uniquely suited to the
geology, climate and geography of this area. It is also noted within Exhibit Six
that Santa Ynez Valley AVA is generally considered to be too warm to grow
premium Pinot Noir and Chardonnay -- and labeling these wines (grown in Santa Rita
Hills) with the current 'Santa Ynez Valley' appellation is deleterious to the
business practices of wineries purchasing Santa Rita Hills
fruit.

Evidence Relating to the Geographical Characteristics
which Distinguish the Viticultural Features of the Proposed Area from Surrounding Area:
(a) Climate: The Santa Ynez Valley AVA, east of U.S. Highway 101, is
well-known for the production of high quality Bordeaux and Rhone varietal
winegrapes: Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc, Merlot, Sauvignon Blanc,
Mourvedre, and other varietals that require significantly higher temperatures
(degree days) for adequate ripening. The Santa Ynez Valley AVA clearly
represents (in the minds of consumers and winemakers alike) warmer climate,
Region Two winegrape cultivars. Varietals more suited to Region One growing
areas (i.e. Santa Rita Hills AVA) such as Chardonnay and Pinot Noir, which are
the predominant plantings within the proposed AVA boundaries, are viticulturally
and climatically distinct from the same varietals grown in the eastern part of
the Santa Ynez Valley AVA. Large, established wineries that used to have
significant plantings of Pinot Noir in the eastern portion of Santa Ynez Valley
AVA (Firestone and Zaca Mesa Wineries specifically) have grafted these vines to
warm-climate varietals after being disappointed by the results. Specifically, it
is much more difficult to gain a balance of high ripeness to strong acid content
in cool-climate varietals grown in the eastern Santa Ynez Valley. In this
capacity, the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA will correctly identify and
distinguish a unique cool-climate wine-production area of Santa Barbara County,
California.
The climatic features of the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA are striking when contrasted with
the Eastern Santa Ynez Valley. As evidenced by the following comparative study
of University of California weather-station records, records from the national
Weather Service, the Western Regional Climate Center, the National Climatic Data
Center and those of the CIRIS Weather Station system accessed in Santa Ynez and
Cachuma Lake (which is located within the eastern boundary of the Santa Ynez
Valley AVA), it is clear that ambient temperature and evapotranspiration rates
during veraison and ripening are surprisingly disparate for two adjacent
viticultural locales. (See extensive climatic documentation in Exhibit Two). The
following study summarizes the climatic data found in Exhibit Two.

The following study details ripening temperatures in Fahrenheit.
Note the difference between Lompoc, CA (Western Boundary of the proposed Santa Rita Hills
AVA) and Cachuma Lake -- (the Eastern boundary of the existing Santa Ynez Valley AVA, CA):
| Average Lompoc, CA |
Average Cachuma Lake, CA |
High Temps W.R.C.C.
1950-1997 |
High Temps W.R.C.C.
1952-1997 |
| June: 71.1 |
June: 83.6 |
| July: 72.7 |
July: 89.9 |
| Aug: 73.6 |
Aug: 90.5 |
| Sept: 75.3 |
Sept: 87.5 |
|
| Ambient Temperature Differential During Ripening (Post-Veraison) |
| June: |
Diff: 12.5 deg. F. hotter in Santa Ynez Valley AVA |
| July: |
Diff: 17.2 deg. F. hotter in Santa Ynez Valley AVA |
| August: |
Diff: 16.9 deg. F hotter in Santa Ynez Valley AVA |
| September: |
Diff: 12.2 Deg. F hotter in Santa Ynez Valley AVA |
|
***Average post-veraison ripening temperatures: 14.7 Deg F. hotter within Santa Ynez Valley AVA.***
Heating Degree Day Differential Between Lompoc (Proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA) and Santa Ynez Valley AVA
| Heating Degree Days for Base 50 Degrees Fahrenheit: |
|
Lompoc:
|
Western Boundary of Santa Rita Hills AVA |
Cachuma Lake: |
Eastern Boundary of Santa Ynez Valley AVA |
| Annual: |
92 Heating Degree Days |
Annual: |
153 Heating Degree Days |
|
***Heating Degree Day Differential: 61 Heating Degree Days***
These marked temperature differences are a result of a unique set of geographical, geological
and climatic influences, mostly coastal in origin. Unlike the Santa Ynez Valley
AVA, east of U.S. Highway 101 and the Buellton Flats, the proposed Santa Rita
Hills AVA is situated within a clearly defined transverse (east/west) maritime
throat -- the most clearly delineated east/west transverse range from Alaska to
Chile on the Pacific Coast. This means that the Santa Rita Hills are uniquely
susceptible to the ocean's cooling influence; enabling diurnal ocean breezes
direct access to the coastal valleys between the Purisima Hills and the Santa
Rosa Hills -- the area where the Santa Rita Hills are the dominant feature. This
coastal influence is not nearly as pronounced in the Santa Ynez Valley east of
U.S. Highway 101 and the Buellton Flats, as evidenced by the temperature study
above -- and therefore gives Santa Rita Hills growers the perfect climate for
Davis Region One winegrape varieties (i.e. Pinot Noir, Chardonnay). Our close
proximity to the Pacific Ocean allows coastal fog to fill the hills and valleys
of the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA in the late night and early morning hours,
intensifying the cool-climate influence on varietal winegrape production between
the geological boundaries of the Purisima Hills and the Santa Rosa Hills.
(b) Topography: The topography of the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA is
measurably distinct and isolated from the rest of the Pacific Coast, the Central
Coast, and more specifically, the Santa Ynez Valley east of U.S. Highway 101 and
the Buellton Flats -- where our current AVA is centered. At the heart of the
proposed American Viticultural Area boundary are the Santa Rita Hills, clearly
demarcated on the enclosed USGS topographical maps (Exhibit Seven). The AVA
boundary is demarcated on the north by the Purisima Hills and on the south by
the Santa Rosa Hills -- it is these two east-west oriented ranges that frame the
interior of the Santa Rita Hills AVA.
Within these boundaries, the aforementioned committee of growers, consultants and winemakers
physically surveyed the land on maps, on foor, and off-road in trucks, to
determine what locales were the logical 'edges' of the proposed AVA. Taken into
account in placing the outer limits of the boundary were the following criteria:
viticultural viability, primarily hillside and alluvial basin plantings, and the
coastal influence suitable for cool-climate still winegrape production. Where
those elements were evident and inclusive, the committee included them on a
'rough draft' map that was revised and re-marked many times, both in the field
and at larger meetings with the entire Santa Rita Hills Growers Committee. The
proposed AVA borders on the enclosed USGS Quadrangle Maps (Exhibit Seven)evolved
consistently and deliberately as a result of a determined effort by vintners,
growers and consultants to accurately describe the Santa Rita Hills as a
cool-climate, hillside oriented winegrowing region. The vast majority of the
wineries involved with the establishment of the 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA source
winegrapes from both the east and the west sides of the Santa Ynez Valley AVA,
and are interested in distinguishing them with separate AVA labels to ensure
viticultural, enological and market-based distinctiveness.
The actual topography of the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA is an oak studded, hill-laden
maritime throat that runs east to west, a few miles east of Lompoc to a few
miles west of the Buellton Flats. The coastal influence enters from the west,
through Lompoc, and abruptly loses its influence at the proposed eastern
boundary as demarcated on the enclosed USGS maps. Elevations within the proposed
boundary range from near sea-level to ridge-lines 1800 feet above sea
level.
(c) Soils:
The soils of the Santa Rita Hills are broken down from an array of geological parent material.
The most common soil types within the boundaries are sandy loams, loams, silt
loams and clay loams, based on large percentages of dune sand, marine deposits,
recent alluvium, riverwash and terrace deposits that are visible on the enclosed
U.S.G.S. Survey Maps 1905a and 1905b (Exhibit One).
As evidenced by extensive soil samples (Exhibit Five) from selected sites within the proposed
Santa Rita Hills AVA and the adjacent Santa Ynez Valley AVA, as well as the
letter of support from vineyard consultant Jeff Newton, it is clear that the
soils of Santa Ynez Valley AVA and the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA are
distinct -- namely as a result of a high percentage of alluvial and marine sand
evident within the proposed boundaries of the Santa Rita Hills AVA. The soil
samples from Eastern Santa Ynez show a higher percentage of gravelly and clay
loams, while the samples from the proposed Santa Rita Hills AVA area show higher
percentages of sand, silt, and sandy loams. Maps contained within Exhibit One
(page one)show U.S.G.S. estimates of alluvial sand deposits in the Santa Rita
area of Santa Barbara County.
Proposed Boundaries:
The proposed 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA is located in Northern Santa Barbara County,
California -- east of Lompoc (U.S. Highway 1) and west of Buellton (U.S. Highway
101), using specific hilltops in the Purisima Hills to the north and the Santa
Rosa Hills to the south as boundaries. The precise boundaries can be found on
six U.S. Geological Survey Quadrangle Maps labeled:
- "Lompoc, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1982);
- "Lompoc Hills, Caif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photoinspected 1971);
- "Los Alamos, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1974);
- "Santa Rosa Hills, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photoinspected 1978);
- "Solvang, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1982).
(a) Name. The name of the viticultural area described in this section is 'Santa Rita Hills'.
(b) Approved maps. The appropriate maps for determining the boundaries of the 'Santa Rita Hills' AVA are six (6) U.S.G.S. quadrangle maps. They are entitled:
- "Lompoc, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1982);
- "Lompoc Hills, Caif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photoinspected 1971);
- "Los Alamos, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1974);
- "Santa Rosa Hills, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photoinspected 1978);
- "Solvang, Calif.", 7.5 minute series, edition of 1959 (photorevised 1982).
(c) Boundaries. The 'Santa Rita Hills' viticultural area is
located within Santa Barbara County, California. The beginning point is found on
the Solvang, California Quadrangle U.S.G.S. map at an unnamed hilltop, elevation
1600 feet, in section 27, T.6 N, R. 32 W.
- Then north and slightly west 2.3 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1174 feet, Section 15, T. 6 N., R. 32 W.
- Then west and slightly north 1.85 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 899 feet within the heart of the Santa Rosa Land Grant, T. 6 N., R. 32 W.
- Then north approximately 2 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1063 feet within the north-eastern part of the Santa Rosa Land Grant, T. 7 N., R. 32 W.
- Then northwest 1.1 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 961 feet. Section 29, T. 7 N., R. 32 W.
- Then north and slightly east 1.1 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1443 feet. Section 20, T. 7 N., R. 32 W.
- Then west 1.4 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1479 feet. Section 24, T. 7 N., R. 33 W.
- Then north 1.2 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1705 feet. Section 13, T. 7 N., R. 33 W.
- Then northwest approximately 2 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1543. Section 10, T. 7 N., R. 33 W.
- Then west and slightly south 1.6 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 935 feet within the northern section of the Santa Rosa Land Grant. T. 7 N., R. 33 W.
- Then south by southwest 1.5 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 605 feet in the northern section of the Santa Rosa Land Grant. T. 7 N., R. 33 W.
- Then west by southwest approximately 2 miles to the point where California Highway 246 intersects with the 200 foot elevation contour line comprising the western border of the Santa Rita Hills, within the Santa Rosa Land Grant. T. 7 N., R. 34 W.
- Then following the 200 foot elevation contour line south along the western border of the Santa Rita Hills to an extreme southern tip of the 200 foot elevation contour line that is .6 miles due west of an unnamed hilltop 361 feet in elevation in the Canada de Salsipuedes Land Grant. T. 6 N., R. 34 W.
- Then southeast 2.35 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1070 feet. Section 18. T. 6 N., R. 33 W.
- Then east and slightly south 1.95 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 921 feet. Section 16. T.6 N., R. 33 W.
- Then east by southeast 1.35 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1307 feet. Section: on intersection between Sections 22 and 23. T. 6 N., R. 33 W.
- Then east 2.35 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation 1507 feet in the southern area of the Santa Rosa Land Grant. T. 6 N., R. 32. W.
- Then east by southeast 2.1 miles to an unnamed hilltop elevation1279 feet in the southern area of the Santa Rosa Land Grant. T. 6 N., R. 32 W.
- Then east by southeast 1.45 miles to the point of beginning.

|